Have you heard about the metabolic confusion diet plan? It’s been popular lately, so you might be wondering whether it could help you manage obesity.

Before you decide to try the metabolic confusion diet, it’s important to understand what it is, its possible benefits, and the risks. Then, you and your healthcare provider can decide whether this eating plan might be right for you.

What’s a Metabolic Confusion Diet?

The metabolic confusion diet is also called calorie cycling or the calorie shifting diet. In a metabolic confusion diet, you intentionally alternate between high-calorie days and low-calorie days. The idea is to increase and decrease the number of calories you eat in specific ways on specific days.

The goal of this diet is to prevent your metabolism from adapting to a consistent calorie deficit, as it might with a more traditional diet. Your metabolism is how your body turns what you eat and drink into energy. When you cut calories significantly, your metabolism can slow down, causing your body to use or burn energy less efficiently. Because your metabolism doesn’t always need to work at the same rate, the idea behind calorie cycling is to help it work more effectively.

There are several ways to approach metabolic confusion. Some people try intermittent fasting, where they don’t eat between certain hours or eat only on alternating days. Others vary their calorie intake from day to day while focusing on protein as their main nutrient.

What Are the Benefits of the Metabolic Confusion Diet?

There are a few ways you might benefit from the metabolic confusion diet. Some of these benefits are theoretical, while others have some evidence behind them. It’s important to note that there aren’t a lot of studies looking specifically at metabolic confusion. Additionally, there’s no evidence yet showing whether it helps people not only lose weight but also maintain that weight loss long term.

One study involving 74 participants compared a traditional calorie-restricted diet with a calorie-cycling (metabolic confusion) diet over six weeks. Participants who followed the cycling diet showed greater improvements in blood glucose, triglyceride, and cholesterol levels compared to those on the calorie-restricted diet. They also found it easier to stick to the cycling diet than the calorie-restricted one. However, the study authors emphasized that larger and longer-term studies are needed to determine whether the cycling diet is effective and safe over time.

Another review analyzed five other studies comparing calorie-restricted diets and metabolic confusion diets. The studies lasted an average of 26 weeks, ranging from 14 to 48 weeks. Overall, both diets were found to be equally effective when it came to lowering body weight. Researchers suggested that metabolic confusion may be a viable alternative to traditional calorie-restricted diets when it comes to weight loss, though more research is needed to assess its long-term benefits and risks.

Another study involving 100 people compared three groups: one that continued their normal diet, one that followed a calorie-restricted diet, and one that followed a calorie-cycling diet. This study found no added benefits to the cycling diet compared to the calorie-restricted one. In fact, participants following the cycling diet may have had higher levels of LDL (“bad” cholesterol) after 12 months than those in the other groups.

Some other potential benefits of cycling diets include supporting both fat loss and muscle building. As noted above, calorie cycling could also affect how metabolism works. More research is needed to determine whether the metabolic confusion diet has lasting metabolic effects.

Everyone’s metabolism responds differently to calorie changes. Factors like genetics, body composition, hormones, sleep, stress, and activity level all influence how your body uses and stores energy. Because of this, results can vary widely from person to person, even among people following similar diets.

What Are the Risks of Metabolic Confusion?

There are a few potential risks to keep in mind if you’re considering a calorie-cycling or metabolic confusion diet.

If your low-calorie days are too restrictive, or if you feel like you’re hungry all the time because your daily calorie intake is too low, the diet may not be safe or sustainable for you. You could develop nutritional imbalances if your meals aren’t well balanced — especially without guidance from a registered dietitian. Some people may also develop disordered eating patterns, where thoughts about food, eating habits, or body image start to feel obsessive or unhealthy.

Additionally, some diets aren’t healthy for people with certain medical conditions. This will depend on your medical diagnoses and the particular diet you’re considering. Before starting any new diet, it’s best to consult your endocrinologist or another healthcare provider to make sure it’s safe for you and won’t cause unintended harm.

Is the Metabolic Confusion Diet Good for Obesity?

While the metabolic confusion diet may help some people living with obesity, other ways of eating are generally considered healthier and safer.

There are many types of eating plans available. It’s best to avoid diets that promise rapid weight loss, require you to combine specific foods, or are overly rigid about what you can and can’t eat.

The most effective diet plan is one you can maintain long term — one that includes foods you enjoy while providing balanced nutrition. Your diet plan should offer a wide variety of foods that supply the nutrients, vitamins, and minerals that your body needs (this should include foods that you like eating and taste good to you). Diets that fit this description include the Mayo Clinic diet, the DASH diet, and the Mediterranean diet. These diets promote overall healthy eating and help reduce the risks associated with overly restrictive diets.

If you’re drawn to a particular version of the metabolic confusion diet, it may work for you — research suggests that some people do find success with this approach. However, it’s essential to understand how to follow it safely. Talking with your doctor or a registered dietitian can help you tailor the plan to your specific needs and goals.

Talk to Your Doctor

Before you start any new diet, always talk to a healthcare professional. They can help identify underlying factors contributing to obesity, such as genetics, hormones, and lifestyle choices. If dieting is right for you, your provider can recommend safe strategies for achieving or maintaining a healthy weight. They may also help you figure out a meal plan and ingredient list and give you grocery shopping tips.

In some cases, your doctor may refer you to a registered dietitian. Dietitians specialize in creating personalized nutrition plans that align with your preferences, lifestyle, and health goals. They can also help you find enjoyable recipes that support your wellness and well-being.

Join the Conversation

On MyObesityTeam, people share their experiences with obesity, get advice, and find support from others who understand.

Have you tried the metabolic confusion diet? Let others know in the comments below.